Loading DutchList...
Freshly baked Pennsylvania‑Dutch pies, whoopie pies, sticky buns & treats made daily onsite.
Photos are taken respectfully and with permission. We honor Amish customs regarding photography.
Yoder’s Country Market Bakery in New Holland has been warming hearts with Pennsylvania‑Dutch baked goods for decades. Their bakery features traditional offerings like Wet‑Bottom Shoo‑Fly Pie, whoopie pies (including seasonal flavors), cinnamon sticky buns, fruited crumb pies, muffins, brownies, and more—all made daily from scratch. They also fulfill custom orders for weddings and special events.
Bakery hours may extend seasonally; holiday hours vary.
Call ahead for custom wedding cakes or large dessert orders.
Ample lot shared with market; trailers welcome.
Morning hours for freshest pies and buns.
Preparing map...